This is why your blues solos are "noodley"


Reader,

When we play the blues, we can use the blues scale over all of the chords. That scale gives you all the right bluesy colors.

So, why do so many blues solos sound "noodley" and uninspired?

Before I explain, listen to the head of Sandu by Clifford Brown. Specifically, listen for how each phrase ends.

video preview​

Sandu

Clifford Brown
Max Roach Quintet

Notice how almost every phrase of this melody ends on beat one (or the and-of-four, but that's just anticipating beat one)

When I started improvising, I treated beat one as the start of my lines. But the great blues players treat beat one as the destination.

Check it out here on Autumn Leaves too...

And Blue Bossa too...

...where each phrase of the melody is driving you into beat one.

Anyway, back to the blues.

Here's the bit that surprised me most. The chord tone you aim for on beat one doesn't have to come from the blues scale. In fact, it's better when it doesn't.

If you only use notes from the blues scale, then you can't tell the difference between the chords. But, when you land on a chord tone, the root, third, fifth, or seventh, the line itself outlines the chord, so a listener can hear the implied harmony, even without anyone playing the chords.

The third of each chord is especially strong at defining the harmony, like you see often in the Autumn Leaves and Blue Bossa examples.

Bad, Noodly Example:

Now, let's compare this to the kind of bad "noodley" line that old Josh would have played. Notice how all the blues scale notes work fine over the chords, but the lines feel like they don't have any direction.

Better, Less Noodly Example:

And here's almost the same line, but with the rhythms shifted forward so the target notes land on the beat. And in a couple cases, I aimed for the 3rds of the chords instead of blues scale notes.

What to expect from Jazz-Library this Black Friday

I'm launching a brand new video course on playing the jazz blues.

Most blues lessons teach the same things... the 12 bar blues form, and the blues scale. But basically none of them show you how to actually use those to play creatively and authentically. And I really felt the need to contribute that.

I've been working on this course all year. I tested and refined the method in our live members workshops and adjusted the approach based on that feedback. I'm very happy with how it's come together.

And of course, because it's Black Friday, it's going to launch at a huge discount.

As a Jazz-Library member, you'll get early access to the course automatically in the coming weeks.

I will let you know when it's available in your account.

Your Practice Plan

  1. Map out target notes to aim for on each beat one
  2. Go through each, one at a time, exploring different ways to hit that target
  3. Practice soloing over the whole blues head, finding these chord tone targets spontaneously.

Now, aiming your lines at beat one is exactly the kind of thing I felt was missing from most blues lessons. Which brings me to what I've been working on.

Happy Practicing,

Josh Walsh

Want to be friends on Instagram or Facebook?

​

Did a Friend FWD you this email?

​Subscribe here​

Your Email Preferences

Your email address is: Reader

​Change your account details

​Don't notify me about live workshops​

​Unsubscribe me from this newsletter​

Jazz-Library is located at:

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246

​

Subscribe to Josh Walsh @ Jazz-Library